ISLAMABAD:
A parliamentary panel on Thursday sought clarification on the Election Amendment Bill 2026, which proposes transferring election petitions from the Supreme Court to the Federal Constitutional Court (FCC), after the government and the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) expressed support for the proposed change.
The bill, introduced by Senators Tahir Khalil and Abdul Qadir, came under discussion at a Senate Standing Committee on Law and Justice meeting chaired by Senator Farooq H Naek.
The panel questioned whether the proposed amendment amounted to a minor procedural change, as claimed by its sponsors and the government, or would have wider implications for the jurisdiction of the country’s superior courts.
It directed the ECP and the Ministry of Law and Justice to brief it on the proposed change in the appellate forum for election disputes.
Officials from the Election Commission, including its secretary law, attended the meeting.
Asked by the committee chairman about the ECP’s position on the bill, the secretary law said the commission agreed with transferring election disputes to the FCC following the 27th Constitutional Amendment.
Senator Shahadat Awan suggested that the bill should instead be referred to the election reforms committee for review, saying it would be better to have the proposed legislation examined by that forum.
However, Farooq H Naek said there was still no clarity about the election reforms committee and that even its membership had not been finalised. Senator Abdul Qadir also pointed out that some political parties had yet to agree to participate in the committee.
The chairman said it would be better for the Senate committee to discuss the bill, following which it began examining its provisions.
Questioning the rationale behind the proposed change, Naek asked why the sponsors wanted election petitions to be heard by the FCC instead of the SCd.
Senator Khalil Tahir, the mover of the bill, responded that following the 27th Amendment, the FCC had become the superior forum in constitutional matters and should therefore hear election disputes instead of the SC.
The government also extended its support to the legislation introduced by Senators Tahir Khalil and Abdul Qadir.
Minister of State for Law and Justice Barrister Aqeel Malik said it was a minor amendment involving the transfer of legal matters relating to elections to a higher court.
However, Naek disagreed, saying the proposed transfer of election petitions to the FCC was not a minor change.
The Secretary Law and Justice pointed out that matters relating to the right of association under Article 17 of the Constitution would also come before the FCC.





